Struggling to lose weight no matter what you try? In this Quick Hits episode, Karen Martel cuts through the noise around dieting and exercise myths and gets to what actually derails women in midlife — self-deception, the on/off diet cycle, and negative self-talk. In under 15 minutes, you'll get practical strategies for building sustainable habits and the mindset shifts that make lasting wellness possible.

 

If you've ever started a new diet on Monday, fallen off by Thursday, and told yourself you'd start again next week — this episode is for you.

This Quick Hits episode pulls from one of the most replayed conversations on The Hormone Solution Podcast, and it's easy to understand why. Karen digs into the real reasons women struggle to lose weight in midlife, and it has far less to do with willpower or the right diet plan than most of us are led to believe. The culprits are subtler: the stories we tell ourselves, the all-or-nothing thinking we've normalized, and the diet culture myths we've been absorbing for decades.

If you're a woman in perimenopause or menopause, sustainable weight loss requires more than cutting carbs or logging steps. It requires honesty — with yourself, about your habits, your excuses, and the environments you've built around you. This episode is a reset for your mindset, not just your metabolism.

Listen on Apple Podcasts

In This Episode, We Discuss

• How self-deception and lack of self-awareness can quietly undermine your wellness goals
• Why the on/off diet mentality hinders long-term health and weight loss success
• How to identify and use your personal strengths to create sustainable habits
• The most common dieting and exercise myths — and how to move past them
• Why harmful diet fads cause yo-yo weight loss and what to do instead
• The role of positive thinking in reaching your wellness goals
• How to recognize and address negative self-talk in real time
• Why exploring root causes of overeating is more effective than following strict rules
• How to set realistic, achievable goals that support lasting weight loss
• Why your home environment plays a bigger role in your habits than willpower
• How finding enjoyable movement transforms your relationship with exercise
• Why balance — not extreme restriction — is the key to a sustainable diet

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do I keep failing at diets even when I start with good intentions?

The on/off diet cycle is one of the most common reasons women feel like they can't succeed. When you frame health as something you're either doing perfectly or failing at entirely, any small slip feels like a reason to give up altogether. Sustainable weight loss is built through consistent, imperfect effort over time — not through perfect streaks followed by total collapses. Shifting away from all-or-nothing thinking is often the first and most important step.

How does self-sabotage affect weight loss?

Self-sabotage often operates beneath conscious awareness. It can look like rationalizing habits that aren't serving you, setting goals you don't actually believe you can reach, or using stress or emotional discomfort as a trigger to abandon healthy routines. Building honest self-awareness — without shame or self-criticism — helps you recognize these patterns before they derail your progress.

Is negative self-talk really connected to weight loss struggles?

Yes. Research consistently shows that how you think about yourself and your body influences your behavior and your outcomes. Women who engage in harsh self-criticism after a perceived failure are more likely to abandon their goals entirely. A long-term, compassionate mindset supports consistent action far better than a punishing inner voice does.

What's wrong with cutting out entire food groups to lose weight?

Extreme elimination diets may produce short-term results, but they tend to be unsustainable and can lead to nutrient deficiencies, rebound weight gain, and a disordered relationship with food. For women in perimenopause and menopause, whose hormone changes already affect metabolism and hunger signals, a balanced approach to eating is generally more effective and far gentler on the body.

How do I stop eating out of stress or boredom?

Before addressing the behavior, it helps to understand what's driving it. Overeating is often a coping mechanism for stress, loneliness, boredom, or unmet emotional needs. Simply imposing stricter food rules on top of those unresolved drivers rarely works long-term. Exploring what's actually underneath the urge to eat — and finding alternative ways to meet those needs — is a more effective and compassionate approach.

What kind of exercise is best for weight loss in midlife?

The best exercise is one you'll actually do consistently. For women in perimenopause and menopause, strength training is particularly beneficial because it supports muscle mass, metabolic health, and bone density — all of which shift during hormonal changes. That said, if you dread your workouts, it's worth experimenting with different forms of movement until you find something that feels good. Enjoyment dramatically improves long-term adherence.

How do I set realistic weight loss goals that I'll actually stick to?

Realistic goals account for where you actually are right now — not where you think you should be. They're specific, time-aware, and graduated enough to build momentum without overwhelming you. For women in midlife, goals also need to factor in hormonal changes that influence metabolism, body composition, and energy. Working with a clinician who understands the full picture of your health gives you far better benchmarks than a generic chart or app.

About Karen Martel

Karen Martel is a Certified Hormone Specialist and Transformational Nutrition Coach who founded Midlife Solutions to address the gap in personalized women's hormonal healthcare. She specializes in bioidentical HRT, comprehensive hormone testing, and clinical coaching for women in perimenopause and menopause.