Current Diagnosis and Treatment of Hypothyroidism are Both Fundamentally Flawed by Paul Robinson
I have recently been given a new paper written by Professor Rudolf Hoermann, Mel Rowe and Peter Warmingham. The three authors have joined forces to produce to try and improve patients’ knowledge of effective diagnosis and treatment of hypothyroidism. The title of their paper is, “A Patient’s Guide to the Diagnosis and Treatment of Hypothyroidism”. I will provide a link to the paper at the end.
When I was sent the paper by one of the authors. I read it and responded immediately with:
‘It is a brief, simply-explained, to-the-point and altogether excellent paper”.
The paper is extremely worth reading and may help many thyroid patients in discussions with doctors or endocrinologists. Of course, sometimes, the doctor you may be speaking with may be very certain of their point of view. They may not even realize that what they have been taught was only introduced post-1985 when the TSH assay was created. These post-1985 views that are currently being used by most doctors and endocrinologists have now been shown to be very flawed, and this new paper by the three authors points this out very clearly.
The paper points out several major FLAWS in current diagnosis and treatment. I will pick out the major ones listed in the paper, all of which have now been refuted by extensive scientific evidence:
1. A subnormal assessment of free T4 (FT4) serves to establish a diagnosis of hypothyroidism. Also, TSH is exquisitely sensitive to minor changes in FT4, leading to the adoption of TSH as “the single best screening test for primary thyroid dysfunction for the vast majority of outpatient clinical situations.”
2. T4 is converted to T3 as needed, leading to treatment being changed to levothyroxine (T4) only.
3. TSH within its reference range represents euthyroidism (normal), leading to the treatment dosage of T4 being adjusted to return TSH within its normal range.
All three of the above assumptions are fundamental to current guidelines for doctors and endocrinologists. They need to be replaced with new guidelines that fit the science and help far more thyroid patients fully recover.
We know TSH does NOT correlate to symptomatic improvement and that low TSH does not mean someone is overtly hyperthyroid.
We now know that improvement in serum FT3 concentrations correlates to symptomatic improvement. We also know that conversion from T4 to T3 does not always work well. Only the T3 hormone provides genomic effect in the cells of the body.
We also know that the clinical presentation of the patient and symptom improvement should be at the forefront of treatment and that any lab assessment of thyroid hormones must include FT3 as well as TSH, FT4 and possibly Reverse T3.
The paper supports all of the statements with research references.
The authors recommend what ought to be done instead of the current practices. These recommendations include the focus on patients’ symptoms, what testing really needs to be done and which labs are the ones to see improvement in. This is what needs to happen and it is what my books and website have been saying for many years. Eventually, this will happen!
I highly recommend reading it. Many thanks to all three authors of the paper!
Here is the link to the new paper:
Best wishes,
Paul
Paul Robinson
Find Karen Martel on Apply Podcast
Karen Martel is a Certified Hormone Specialist and Transformational Nutrition Coach dedicated to empowering women through their health journeys.
As the host of the popular podcast The Hormone Solution, Karen tackles the complexities of hormonal health, weight loss resistance, and the challenges that come with perimenopause and menopause.
Her mission is to disrupt outdated narratives surrounding women's health, providing reliable information and practical solutions that help women reclaim their vitality. With personal experience overcoming her own health struggles, Karen offers insights into hormone optimization and sustainable weight management strategies.
Join her as she engages in enlightening conversations with experts and shares actionable advice, all aimed at helping women navigate their unique hormonal landscapes with confidence and clarity. Tune in to discover how to embrace life's stages while enhancing overall well-being.
Listen to more
Midlife Fitness: Cutting Through the Hype and doing What Really Works with Ulrich Dempfle
by
Bored of the same old cardio routine that feels more like a chore than a benefit? What if you could transform your fitness in just five minutes? Ulrich Dempfle joins us today to introduce the CAROL Bike and REHIT technology, promising a cardio revolution. Join us as we explore the science behind barely breaking a sweat while reaping impressive fitness rewards. Can a 5-minute workout really improve your VO2 max by over 12% in just weeks? How can AI personalize your exercise routine for maximum results? Discover how the CAROL Bike addresses our evolutionary instincts to conserve energy and fits seamlessly into our busy lives. Wondering why Olympic athletes are raving about a stationary bike? Could this be the solution to the time-crunch dilemma we all face? This episode is packed with inspiring stories and actionable insights to shift your perspective on exercise and health forever.
Round Table with The Meno Besties: Meno Myths, Midlife Madness & The Hormone Truth Bombs You Need to Hear
by
Are you tired of the myths and misinformation surrounding menopause? Ever wonder why hormone replacement therapy is so misunderstood? This episode goes right into the complex world of menopause, revealing truths that challenge outdated beliefs, guided by Zora Benhamou and Dr. Fiona Lovely. How does culture impact menopause experiences, and what misconceptions need to be shattered? Join us as we discuss the real implications of menopause beyond hot flashes. How do hormone changes affect brain and joint health, and why are they often overlooked? What are the global gaps in menopause knowledge, and how can we bridge them?